Archive for the ‘load balancing’ tag
Whew! I just finished a marathon of revisions. It’s been a while since I posted about our progress, so here’s an update for the curious readers.
I just finished revising the last two major chapters that Peter Zaitsev hasn’t yet reviewed. Peter has been essentially going through the chapters like a very thorough technical reviewer. He makes corrections, points out where things aren’t clear or need examples, and adds more material.
By “finished revising,” I mean finished expanding the outline into a full chapter. We’re still working at the level of “this chapter is mostly there, but we might decide to revise it more.” We will most certainly do so in many cases. There are some chunks of material that I’ve marked TODO to put into other chapters, for example. We’re not at the level of a final draft with any chapter except the chapter on MySQL’s architecture, but we’re getting close with the others now.
Most of the chapters are in tech review now, and we’ve gotten a few of them back. The comments from the reviewers have been very helpful. We expanded the Replication chapter quite a bit after tech review. (And then Peter reviewed it and we expanded it even more). When the tech reviewers return comments on the other chapters, we’ll revise some more.
We’re up to 529 pages in OpenOffice.org now. At my calculated ratio of 1 page = 1.1 pages in print, that’s about 582 pages in print. And that’s not counting the Replication chapter, which doesn’t have all of its illustrations yet. I predicted we’d break 500 pages; we might get close to 600. These are very, very densely written, too. No offense to the first edition, but the tone is quite different; much less light-hearted banter, much more compressed information. Peter is a walking encyclopedia, and never seems to run out of details we really ought to include because they’re important (and they are).
We may, or may not, go to production in the next few weeks. Regardless, I think we’re still on track to have the book on shelves by the MySQL Conference & Expo in April. Look for me there. I’ll be easy to find: I’ll be the tall guy with a permanent silly grin. (You’d grin too if you finished writing a book that’s been this much work!)
I’ve posted rough outlines for many of the other chapters. The two Peter and I just finished working on are the Scaling/HA/Load-Balancing/Failover chapter, and the Application-Level Optimization chapter. The Scaling/HA chapter is pretty long and very involved, and goes into a lot of detail on scaling in particular, especially horizontal scaling via sharding. (We use “sharding” because it’s less confusing than calling it “partitioning,” which already means too many different things in databases).
The Application-Level Optimization chapter is a little shorter. It’s mostly about caching strategies, how to make a web server run well, and so on. These aren’t what the book focuses on directly, but you can either help or hurt the database server a lot with your application design. Our goal here is to help people avoid the common mistakes.
For the curious, here’s the current outline for these two chapters:
Scaling and High Availability Terminology Scaling MySQL Planning for Scalability Buying Time Before Scaling Scaling Up Scaling Out Functional Partitioning Data Sharding Choosing a Partitioning Key Multiple Partitioning Keys Querying Across Shards Allocating Data, Shards, and Nodes Arranging Shards on Nodes Fixed Allocation Dynamic Allocation Mixing Dynamic and Fixed Allocation Explicit Allocation Sidebar: Re-Balancing Shards Tools for Sharding Scaling Back Keeping Active Data Separate Scaling by Clustering Clustering Federation Load Balancing Connecting Directly Splitting Reads and Writes in Replication Changing Application Configuration Changing DNS Names Moving IP Addresses Introducing a Middleman MySQL Proxy Load Balancers Load Balancing Algorithms Adding and Removing Servers in the Pool Load Balancing with a Master and Multiple Slaves High Availability Planning for High Availability Adding Redundancy Shared-Storage Architectures Replicated-Disk Architectures Synchronous MySQL Replication Failover and Failback Promoting a Slave or Switching Roles Virtual IP Addresses or IP Takeover MySQL Master-Master Replication Manager Middleman Solutions Handling Failover in the Application
And here’s the outline for the Application-Level Optimization chapter:
Application-Level Optimization Application Performance Overview Find the Source of the Problem Look for Common Problems Web Server Issues Finding the Optimal Concurrency Caching Sidebar: Caching Doesn't Always Help Caching Below the Application Application-Level Caching Cache Control Policies Cache Object Hierarchies Pre-Generating Content Extending MySQL Alternatives to MySQL
The thing that makes me the happiest right now is that we’re clearly going to make it. For a while, there was just so much work left to do that it was impossible to estimate how much. (Ask my wife: I was wrong many times when she asked how long it would take me to finish a chapter). I also didn’t know how much revision would be necessary, which is very scary; revising takes about four times as long as writing a first draft, by my reckoning. At this point, the remaining work is much smaller, and much easier to estimate. And now I no longer flip-flop daily between “I think we can, I think we can” and “please don’t ask, because I don’t know and I want a vacation.”
Subversion shows me that Peter has the Security chapter locked right now. This one is not a huge one, and Arjen Lentz has already reviewed it as well, so I don’t expect it to be a huge amount of work to revise. After that, it’s minor chapters and appendices. (We might actually convert the chapters on Server Status and Tools into appendices, since they got cannibalized when we realized their material fit better elsewhere. They also don’t have a very chapter-ish feel; they feel more like appendices). We’ve added a few more appendices, including one on EXPLAIN and one on debugging server and storage-engine locking problems. These are all great reference material.
See you at the conference in April!
Continuing in the tradition, which I hope has been as helpful to you as it has been to me, I’m opening the floor for suggestions on chapter 9 of the upcoming High Performance MySQL, Second Edition. Unlike the other chapters for which I’ve listed outlines, this one isn’t substantially written yet. It’s in detailed outline form at this point (a tactic that has worked very well for us so far — I’ll write about that someday).
I’m trying to get feedback much earlier in this chapter’s lifecycle, for several reasons. Two of the most important are that this is one of the first chapters I’ve had a chance to really take from scratch, and the chapters I haven’t written from scratch have been harder to organize, as you’ve probably seen from the last few outlines I posted. There’s a lot of value in working top-down on this deep encyclopedia-style material.
The outline, as it stands now, is basically headings with bulleted lists of important details. Here are the top-level headings:
[Intro] Scaling and High Availability Requirements Replication Overview Configuring Replication Under the Hood of Replication Replication Topologies Replication Administration and Maintenance Replication Problems and Solutions The Future of MySQL Replication Scaling MySQL Horizontally Clustering with MySQL MySQL Cluster Other Clustering Solutions Load Balancing
Just a few notes. These sections are top-level, and will likely be split into many sub-sections like other chapter outlines I’ve posted. A typical section has a couple dozen bullet-points in it, at a high level of granularity, such as “Using DRBD for log replication only.” I think we’ll also add in a separate section on fail-over and fail-back, but that’s not in the outline as of right now (what do you think belongs in it?).
I don’t know what it’s like for you to read outlines and see little bits of the book being assembled, but the process of writing this book is just fascinating to me. It’s endlessly interesting and educational — just the process of writing, let alone the subject matter! This is a really fun project. A heck of a lot of work, but fun nonetheless, and the openness of the project makes it even more fun for me. I’ve learned a lot of surprising and interesting things about writing. I keep wishing I had time to write about this process, but I really need to keep my eye on the deadlines and put that off for later.
Anyway, the usual requests apply: what’s missing, what do you think is cool and should be included, etc etc? Thanks, as usual, for your time and feedback.